Is Your SEO Agency Helping or Hurting Your Business?

Get a free marketing audit

1. Branded vs. Non-Branded Search: Who Gets Credit?
2. What Bad SEO Looks Like
3. How to Assess Your SEO Agency's Performance
4. Conclusion: Is Your SEO Agency Destroying Your Site?

Is your SEO agency actually helping, or are they just taking credit for traffic you’d get anyway? Unfortunately, many businesses overpay for SEO services that deliver little value. Let’s explore the common signs of a poor SEO agency and how to assess whether yours is worth the investment.

Branded vs. Non-Branded Search: Who Gets Credit?

Have you ever looked for a specific product in Google, like ‘bluetooth headphones’? Or maybe you have a brand in mind already, so you typed in ‘Sony headphones’. The first search is what’s considered a non-branded search and the second is a branded search since it includes the name of a company, ‘Sony’.

A lot of SEO agencies will claim credit for branded search traffic, even though it’s likely that this traffic would happen without their help. However, the real traffic value comes from non-branded searches as these users who don’t yet know your brand. So, if your agency isn’t bringing in non-branded traffic then it’s likely they’re not doing much for your business.

What Bad SEO Looks Like

There are some major warning signs to look out for which could indicate that your SEO agency isn’t delivering the results that they should. Here are just a few red flags:

1. Vague Reporting

If your agency is delivering reports that are unclear or full of nonsense then they could be hiding poor performance.

2. Low-Quality Backlinks

Badly managed SEO agencies will often hurt your rankings by building links from irrelevant or spammy websites.

3. No Organic Traffic Growth

Your agency’s strategy could be ineffective if your non-branded traffic isn’t seeing any expected increases.

4. Keyword Stuffing

Poor SEO agencies will often fill a web page unnaturally with keywords or numbers to manipulate rankings in Google Search results.

How to Assess Your SEO Agency's Performance

If you’re unsure whether your SEO agency is delivering real value, it’s time to take a closer look at their work. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to evaluate their performance:

1. Set Up Google Search Console

Google Search Console is a free tool that allows you to monitor your website’s performance in search results. Check for increases in non-branded search traffic, keyword rankings, and click-through rates. It’s a huge red flag If your agency isn’t actively tracking these metrics.

2. Track Key Metrics

The key metrics you should be focusing on should be organic traffic growth (especially non-branded traffic), keyword rankings for relevant terms, and backlink quality. If your agency isn’t showing improvements in any of these areas, then you’re probably overpaying for the value they’re providing.

3. Review Link-Building Strategies

A healthy link-building strategy involves earning high-quality links from authoritative sites. If your SEO agency is focusing on quantity over quality or using irrelevant links then they’re definitely doing more harm than good to your site’s rankings.

Conclusion: Is Your SEO Agency Destroying Your Site?

Terrible SEO agencies will always hide behind technical terms and good-looking metrics, making it hard to see the real impact of their efforts (or lack of). If you think your agency might be overcharging or under-delivering, we can help. Book a free SEO audit today, and let us help you get back on track with a strategy that delivers real, measurable results!

Written by Anthony Dutcher

Founding Partner

Disclaimer: The information in these resources may lead to unprecedented online growth, massive engagement, and an overwhelming surge in your business success. Proceed with caution, as we cannot be held responsible for any sudden increase in sales, followers, or popularity. Read at your own risk of becoming wildly successful.

Ready to Turn Insights Into Action?

Reading about strategy is one thing — putting it into practice is where the growth happens. Partner with Vix Media Group to align your marketing with your business goals and start seeing measurable results.

Talk to the experts

Underlying Motivators

Related resources

A 90-day launch workbench reviews instrumentation and tracking exceptions without promising payback inside the horizon.

What a Realistic First 90-Day Marketing ROI Plan Should Measure Before It Promises Payback

Our first 90-day marketing plan prioritizes instrumentation, learning, and scaling decisions, with explicit costs and conversion delays—not a promise of payback by day 90.

A synthetic record reaches a won CRM stage while its source remains unresolved, separating outcome from attribution completeness.

Form Fill to Sale Attribution: How We Trace Every Step Without Pretending the Record Is Complete

We trace the evidence from form acceptance through CRM handoffs and sales outcomes, keeping missing identifiers, incomplete records, and reconciliation gaps visible.

A fictional two-way nurture conversation pauses acquisition messaging after a reply and assigns human follow-up.

The Seven Follow-Up Systems We Use Before Scaling Paid Traffic for a New Brand

Our seven-part follow-up framework tests capture, ownership, nurture, suppression, and recovery before paid traffic scales, keeping lead activity distinct from sales outcomes.

Jesse Christiansen

An illustrative customer-list audience is held because source evidence is missing; activation is disabled.

Before We Used AI Audience Data, We Checked Rights, Sensitive Categories, and Platform Rules

Before activating AI audience data, we examine provenance, permitted use, sensitivity, and platform eligibility. Technical compatibility does not establish data rights.

Tallie Thompson

A synthetic qualified CRM event returns to an ad-platform receipt, where diagnostics still require reconciliation.

Offline Conversion Tracking Is Valuable. It Is Not an AI Advertising Strategy

Offline conversion tracking connects later CRM outcomes to advertising. It improves measurement and feedback without replacing decisions about the offer, market, or sales process.

David Casey

An illustrative new campaign remains paused; enabling delivery is locked behind a separate human approval.

Agentic Ad Management Did Not Reduce Our Work. It Expanded What We Could Inspect

Our agentic ad workflow expands bounded inspection while keeping strategy and approval with people. Each authorized action is followed by a check of the resulting state.

A research workbench compares Viant open-internet advertising, Omneky creative and launch, and Albert campaign optimization as vendor claims.

Three Autonomous Ad Platforms, Three Operating Models: What AI Ad Management Actually Automates

We compared three autonomous ad platforms by operating model, separating vendor capabilities, advertiser authority, and native automation rather than assuming equal autonomy.

David Casey

The planned GA4 ratio divides identifiable AI referral sessions by Organic Search sessions, not Search Console clicks.

AI Referral Traffic and Organic Search Need Different Measurement Rules

AI referrals and organic search follow different measurement rules. We explain why a credible comparison needs verified access, consistent scope, and clear limitations.

An illustrative AI-cited educational guide hands readers to a service comparison; a later form is a separate page role.

AI Citations and Customer Visits: How We Would Test Whether the Surfaced Page Matches the Visited Page

We outline a test comparing AI-surfaced pages with customer visits, explaining why an overlap percentage needs matched evidence rather than an assumed shared journey.

David Casey

A fictional journey moves from an unselected AI citation to a later branded Google search; the causal link is unproven.

AI Search Measurement: How We Would Test Whether AI Visibility Preceded a Google Click

We outline how to test whether AI visibility precedes a Google click, while keeping observed search activity separate from unverified claims about earlier influence.